Favorite Pies 2026 – Quarterfinals

We’ve reached the Quarterfinals in our Favorite Pies voting bracket! The top two favorites in each division are facing off! And it seems like the quintessential favorites. If I had been asked my guess of the top two in each division, I’d have picked these.

They were mostly really solid wins, too. The only close votes were:

  • Quiche over Shepherd’s Pie by 2 votes
  • Cherry Pie over Dutch Apple Pie by 3 votes

Vote now in the Quarterfinal Round!

The deadline is Sunday evening, November 15.

Click the image to view results or use the PDF below