Favorite Pies 2026 – FINAL RESULTS

The winner of Favorite Pie is: Apple Pie!

It beat Key Lime Pie by 6 votes in the final round.

Thanks to everyone who voted. Below is a list of the favorite pies in each division, followed by the complete bracket in JPG and PDF formats.

Orchard Region

  1. Apple Pie
  2. Cherry Pie
  3. Dutch Apple Pie
  4. Peach Pie

Cream & Chocolate Region

  1. Key Lime Pie
  2. French Silk Pie
  3. Lemon Meringue Pie
  4. Turtle Pie

Classic & Custard Region

  1. Pumpkin Pie
  2. Pecan Pie
  3. Custard Pie
  4. Pumpkin Pecan Pie

Savory Region

  1. Chicken Pot Pie
  2. Quiche
  3. Shepherd’s Pie
  4. Cornish Pasty
Click the image to view results or use the PDF below